Putting Religious Bias in Context: How Offline and Online Context Shape Religious Bias in Online Pro-social Lending

SKU
16959

Publication History

Received: June 22, 2020
Revised: September 25, 2020; August 11, 2021; February 18, 2022
Accepted: April 3, 2022
Published Online as Articles in Advance: May 23, 2022
Published Online in Issue: June 1, 2022

https://doi.org/10.25300/MISQ/2022/16959

$15.00
Abstract

Biases in online platforms pose a threat to social inclusion. We examine the influence of a novel source of bias in online philanthropic lending, namely that associated with religious differences. We first propose religion distance as a probabilistic measure of differences between pairs of individuals residing in different countries. We then incorporate this measure into a gravity model of trade to explain variation in country-to-country lending volumes. We further propose a set of contextual moderators that characterize individuals’ offline (local) and online social contexts, which we argue combine to determine the influence of religion distance on lending activity. We empirically estimate our gravity model using data from Kiva.org, reflecting all lending actions that took place between 2006 and 2017. We demonstrate the negative and significant effect of religion distance on lending activity, over and above other established factors in the literature. Further, we demonstrate the moderating role of lenders’ offline social context (diversity, social hostilities, and government favoritism of religion) on the aforementioned relationship to online lending behavior. Finally, we offer empirical evidence of the parallel role of online contextual factors, namely those related to community features offered by the Kiva platform (lending teams), which appear to amplify the role of religious bias. In particular, we show religious team membership is a double-edged sword that has both favorable and unfavorable consequences, increasing lending in general, but skewing said lending toward religiously similar borrowers. Our findings speak to the important frictions associated with religious differences in individual philanthropy; they point to the role of government policy vis-à-vis religious tolerance as a determinant of citizens’ global philanthropic behavior, and they highlight design implications for online platforms with an eye toward managing religious bias.

Additional Details
Author Amin Sabzehzar, Gordon Burtch, Yili Hong, and T.S. Raghu
Year
Volume Forthcoming
Issue Forthcoming
Keywords Religion, contextual factors, crowdfunding, pro-social lending, peer-to-peer lending
Page Numbers
Copyright © 2022 MISQ. All rights reserved.